EconoMonitor

Ed Dolan's Econ Blog

Afghanistan’s Economic Future, Aid, and the Curse of Riches

We hear a lot about the future of Afghanistan after NATO withdrawal in 2014. Most of the speculation focuses on security and politics. Too little of it concerns economics. A pair of new reports, one from the World Bank and the other from the IMF, help fill the gap. If you thought the security and political prognosis was problematic, wait until you read what lies ahead for the country’s economy.

The most striking fact about the Afghan economy is its extreme dependence on foreign aid. As the following World Bank chart shows, in 2010, aid to Afghanistan exceeded the country’s GDP. Only the West Bank, Gaza, and Liberia are equally aid-dependent.

At first glance, it might seem that the vast aid flows must be holding the Afghan economy together, and that without them, things would be even worse. Clearly some of the aid, both military and civilian, is providing real benefits. Still, world experience suggests that countries have limited capacities to absorb aid. When aid exceeds absorptive capacity, it can do more harm than good. Afghanistan, with its exceptionally large aid flows, is at particular risk.

In a 2005 paper with the provocative title, “Is Aid Oil?” Paul Collier asked whether aid, like natural resource rents, can cause a country to fall victim to the “curse of riches.” Based on African experience, Collier found that aid, on average, is more helpful to development than oil, but that simply scaling it up does not necessarily make it more helpful still. He pointed to two main channels through which the curse-of-riches effect of excessive aid flows can undermine the good intentions of donors.

The first channel is the Dutch disease. That malady comes into play when inflows of external funds drive up a country’s real exchange rate. Regardless of the source of incoming funds—aid, oil, mining, or whatever—the rising real exchange rate makes other sectors of the economy less competitive. Activities that compete with imports, especially small farming and small-scale manufacturing, are especially vulnerable. As a result, the benefits of the incoming cash flows will be spread unevenly, with many people losing jobs or income while a relative few prosper.

Afghan statistics are not especially good, but  such data as are available suggest that the Dutch disease is at work there. The IMF report cited earlier contains a chart of the country’s real effective exchange rate, reproduced below. The REER appears to track the IMF data on aid flows rather closely, with spikes in both indicators in 2007/8 and again in 2010/11. A footnote in the IMF report suggests that the Afghan currency is presently overvalued by about 20 percent relative to where it would be with reduced aid flows.

The second channel through which the curse of riches operates is its effect on governance. Too much money flowing into a country with weak institutions leads to corruption. In countries from Nigeria to Russia to Equatorial Guinea, oil revenues are the source of corrupting cash flows, but Collier warns that aid can produce similar effects if it is not subject to public scrutiny and to the controls of a transparent budget process.

Unfortunately, transparency and public scrutiny are deficit goods in Afghanistan. The World Bank report does not mince words.

Aid has funded the delivery of essential services including education and health, infrastructure investments as well as government administration. There have been substantial improvements in the lives of Afghans over the last 10 years as a result of this effort. But these inflows, most outside the Afghan budget, have been so high that inevitable waste and corruption, aid dependency and use of parallel systems to circumvent limited Government absorptive capacity have impeded aid delivery and the building of a more effective Afghan state. . . . Large financial inflows outside the Afghan budget and fragmented aid in a situation of weak governance have been major sources of rents, patronage, and political power.

The IMF comes to a similar conclusion, citing these measures of Afghanistan’s quality of governance:

  • A ranking of 177th among 178 countries in Transparency International’s 2010 Corruption Perception Index.
  • A rank of 160th out of 183 countries in the World Bank’s 2012 Doing Business report, down six places from the previous year.
  • A rating of 2.6 on the World Bank’s Country Policy and Institutional Assessment Index, well below the average of 3.3. The rating is pulled upward a bit by a favorable score for macroeconomic management, but pulled down by low scores for property rights, governance, and the quality of public administration.

If aid has flowed to Afghanistan beyond the country’s absorptive capacity, one might think the country would actually benefit as foreign assistance tails off in coming years. Unfortunately, the main alternative driver for the Afghan economy is mineral wealth, in the form of vast and largely untapped deposits of copper, iron ore, lithium, and rare earths. Experience elsewhere shows that mineral wealth is even more likely than aid to fuel corruption and bring about a curse of riches.

The IMF and the World Bank are fully aware of the threat. They are working hard, in partnership with the Oslo-based Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), to prevent Afghanistan from falling victim to the curse of riches.  Thanks to lots of arm-twisting, Afghanistan has become a candidate member of the EITI. In order to become a full member,the country will be required to put specific reforms in place, including open publication of company payments and government revenues, to ensure that oil and mineral revenues benefit the country’s population at large.

EITI membership is not a magic bullet, however. Consider the case of Nigeria, which committed to join EITI in 2003 and is now a full member. The path to compliance has not been easy. As recently as 2009, an EITI review uncovered “financial discrepancies, mispaid taxes, and system inefficiencies” as well as “numerous issues that call for urgent attention and action by all stakeholders.” Nigeria remains in 134th place on Transparency International’s Corruption Perception Index. True, that is 18 places higher than Russia, which is not an EITI participant, and 42 places higher than Afghanistan, but it is a long way from squeaky-clean.

Neither the IMF nor the World Bank considers Afghanistan to be a hopeless case. It is part of the mission of both organizations to look on the bright side and to outline measures that, if implemented, could help member countries overcome their problems. Here are some of the things that these organizations say will have to happen for Afghanistan to move toward sustainable economic development after 2014:

  • The US and other donor countries will have to ensure that aid is reduced in a gradual and orderly fashion.
  • The Afghan government will have to continue to strengthen public financial management systems and the budget process, and reduce rent-seeking opportunities and leaks in revenue collection, while pursuing public administration reforms effectively and aggressively.
  • The opium economy will, at a minimum, have to remain no larger than it now is.
  • The Afghan economy will have to become more closely connected to the rest of the world, both through removal of trade restrictions and through greatly improved road and rail infrastructure.

If all of these things happen, and if NATO fully meets its political and security goals by 2014, then the United States and its allies will be able to look back on their efforts in Afghanistan and say, “Job well done!” However, failure of any one of the elements—security, political, or economic—would undermine the others. The outcome would very likely be a conflict-ridden, politically fragmented, and abjectly impoverished Afghanistan for years to come, despite all the investments of blood and money made over the last ten years.

22 Responses to “Afghanistan’s Economic Future, Aid, and the Curse of Riches”

Vladislav YakovOctober 24th, 2017 at 10:59 pm

We Can supply Aviation Kerosene,Jet fuel (JP 54-A1,5), Diesel (Gas Oil) and Fuel Oil D2, D6,ETC in FOB/Rotterdam only, serious buyer should contact or if you have serious buyers my seller is ready to close this deal fast contact us below:now base email us (neftegazagent@yandex.ru)

PRODUCT AVAILABLE IN ROTTERDAM/ CI DIP AND PAY IN SELLER EX-SHORE TANK.

Russia D2 50,000-150,000 Metric Tons FOB Rotterdam Port.

JP54 5000,000 Barrels per Month FOB Rotterdam.

JA1 Jet Fuel 10,000,000 Barrels FOB Rotterdam.

D6 Virgin Fuel Oil 800,000,000 Gallon FOB Rotterdam.

E-mail: neftegazagent@yandex.ru
E: neftegazagent@mail.ru
E: neftegazagent@yahoo.com

Best Regards
(Mr.) Vladislav Yakov
Skype: neftegazagent

Thank You

Anatoly VyacheslavSeptember 3rd, 2018 at 11:22 pm

Dear Buyer/ Buyer mandate
We currently have Available FOB Rotterdam/Hosuton for JP54,D2, D6, JetA1 with good and workable procedure, whereby buyer will dip test in seller tank with proof of product.
Kindly Contact us via (anatolyvyacheslavoil@mail.ru) for SCO as soon as possible, so we can move to the next step.

Regards
Anatoly Vyacheslav
Email: anatolyvyacheslavoil@mail.ru
anatolyvyacheslavoil@yandex.ru
skype:anatolyvyacheslavoil

miss vitoriaSeptember 14th, 2018 at 5:52 pm

Health is not just physical health, but also mental, emotional and spiritual well-being. An important part of the healing process for me is to be active in HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS education, support and advocacy. I volunteer in a number of HSV organizations, and in particular Positive Women, because the impact of HSV on women is very different than from men. As once a positive person, I will forever be grateful to God Almighty and Doctor osewe who reached on me when i thought it was all over, Today am happy with my family living free after the medical doctor have confirmed my HSV status Negative, I have never in my life believed that HSV could be cured by any herbal medicine, I want to make sure that HSV never happens to anyone else. We can't prevent HSV by punishment, by stigma and discrimination. It's only through building a safe, supportive and caring environment, that positive people still have hope and they should contact Dr Ebude with this email:hvpnaturalremedyclinic@gmail.com so they can once again be visible in our community, to educate and advocate, to take better care of ourselves and our families. We're someone's daughter, partner, mother, grandmother, sister, aunt. When we have HSV, it impacts on our families too. kindly contact him today and leave stress free, mind you, this spell doctor also have remedy for the following:HIV AIDS, ALS, MND, Epilepsy, Leukemia, Asthma, Cancer, Candida, Gonorrhea,Empty stomach[yin infection] Good luck as you step into greatness.
the doctor's email once again is
hpvnaturalremedyclinic@gmail.com
you can also call him on; +2348127918703

Maksim YaroslavSeptember 23rd, 2018 at 6:20 pm

JP54 – D6 – JET A1 – D2 AVAILABLE ON CI DIP AND PAY FOB ROTTERDAM & HOUSTON

We are an official Oil & Gas Trading Company/Mandate working direct with Russian Petroleum Refinery which deals on Russian Petroleum Product such as JP54, D2, D6, JA-1 with good and workable procedure whereby buyer will dip test in seller tank with proof of product. Kindly Contact us via E-mail: { neftegazconsultant@yandex.ru } for SCO – Soft Offer.

Below are products and quantities available for urgent lift

JP54: Quantity: 500,000-2,000,000 Barrels
JetA1: Quantity: 500,000-2,000,000 Barrels
D2: Quantity: 50,000-150,000 Metric Tons
D6 Virgin: Quantity: 400,000,000-800,000,000 Gallon

Maksim Yaroslav
EMAIL: neftegazconsultant@yandex.ru,
EMAIL: neftegazconsultant@mail.ru
Skype: neftegazconsultant https://neftegaz-energy-consultant.business.site/

AbabOctober 31st, 2018 at 8:32 am

Do You Seek Funds To Pay Off Credits and Debts? { FIFOCapitals@gmail.com } Is Here To Put A Stop To Your Financial Problems. We Offer All Kinds Of Loan (Personal Loan, Commercial Loan, etc.) We Give Out Loan With An Interest Rate Of 1.00%. Interested Applicants Should Contact Us Via Email: FIFOCapitals@gmail.com

Please Fill the Application Form Below:
– Complete Name:
– Loan Amount Needed:
– Loan Duration:
– Purpose Of Loan:
– City / Country:
– Telephone:
– How Did You Hear About Us:

If You Are Interested To Get A Loan Then Kindly Write Us With The Loan Requirement. Please, Contact Us via email: FIFOCapitals@gmail.com,,,

Usmanov AlexieNovember 15th, 2018 at 6:06 pm

For Serious Buyer/ Buyer mandate

We have JP54,D2, D6, JetA1 product in Rotterdam/Houston/Russia for immediate lift with good procedure,where buyer conduct dip test in seller tank with proof of product.
Kindly Contact us via (usmanovoilandgas@yahoo.com) for SCO.

Regards
Usmanov Alexie
email: usmanovoilandgas60@mail.ru,
skype: usmanovoilandgas

VLAHD ANICHKA MISHADecember 24th, 2018 at 4:42 am

I am a Broker to a Direct Mandate working with a reputable refinery, and we are to you, esteem buyers that the petroleum products you are looking for is available in our Tanks and Reservoir for immedaite lift and supply.

SUCH AS
1) JP54
2) JPA1
3) MAZUT
4) AGO
5) LNG
6) LPG
7) D2
8) D6
9) REBCO
10) EN590

Please contact us via our official email address.

E-mail: vlahdanichka_misha@mail.ru
phone :+79067109704
skype id:phoenix.tearsoil@bk.ru

Best Regards
Thank You

VLAHD ANICHKA MISHA

FeliksMarch 1st, 2019 at 10:39 am

JP 54, D2, and D6 EN590,JETA1 AVAILABLE ON FOB DIP AND TEST IN SELLER TANK

AVAILABLE PETROLEUM PRODUCTS ON FOB & CIF BASIS

WE HAVE AVAILABLE PETROLEUM PRODUCTS FROM RELIABLE REFINERY IN RUSSIAN FEDERATION WITH BEST PRICE AND QUALITY.
BELOW PRODUCT ARE AVAILABLE WITH BEST OFFERS – FOB CI DIP AND PAY FOB PRODUCTS AVAILABLE

JP54: Quantity: 500,000-2,000,000 Barrels
D2: Quantity: 50,000-150,000 Metric Tons
D6 Virgin: Quantity: 400,000,000-800,000,000 Gallon

SERIOUS BUYERS PLEASE CONTACT US FOR MORE DETAILS WITH YOUR SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS SO AS TO ENABLE US PROVIDE YOU WITH OUR WORKABLE

PROCEDURE.
Sincerely.

Contact Person: Feliks Andros
Company: LLC GLOBAL NEFTEGAZ
Email: llc-globalneftegaz@bk.ru
Skype: live:e4aada2885c8c198
Whatsapp:+79032245653
English Department

AndrosMarch 1st, 2019 at 10:40 am

Do you need Russian Petroleum products such as
Crude Oil (Basra Light Crude, REBCO)
D2 Diesel Oil EN590
Jet Fuel (JP 54 and Jet A-1)
Mazut M100 (Origin: Russia and Libya)
Unleaded Premium
Kerosene
Gasoline
Natural Gas (LPG, LNG) etc without any hassles and complication?
We are the best mandate company to help you negotiate and close deals without time wastage, the refineries which will represent can supply to you and your buyers petroleum products with our simple and efficient working procedures without any upfront fee.

Contact Person: Feliks Andros
Company: LLC GLOBAL NEFTEGAZ
Email: llc-globalneftegaz@bk.ru
Skype: live:e4aada2885c8c198
Whatsapp:+79032245653

Alexander DimaMarch 21st, 2019 at 12:46 pm

Hello,
we Can supply Aviation Kerosene,Jet fuel (JP 54-A1,5), Diesel (Gas Oil) and Fuel Oil D2, D6,MAZUT, AGO, LNG, LPG, D2, D6, REBCO, EN590…..ETC in FOB/Rotterdam only, serious buyer should contact or if you have serious buyers

my seller is ready to close this deal fast contact us below:now base email us (alexandervladislav88@mail.ru)

PRODUCT AVAILABLE IN ROTTERDAM/ CI DIP AND PAY IN SELLER EX-SHORE TANK.

Russia D2 50,000-150,000 Metric Tons FOB Rotterdam Port.

JP54 5000,000 Barrels per Month FOB Rotterdam.

JA1 Jet Fuel 10,000,000 Barrels FOB Rotterdam.

D6 Virgin Fuel Oil 800,000,000 Gallon FOB Rotterdam.

E-mail: alexandervladislav88@mail.ru
Call/Whatsapp: +79258159436
Skype:alexander dima vladislav
Best Regards
Thank You
Alexander Dima Vladislav

Vladislav YakovApril 2nd, 2019 at 6:23 am

We Can supply Aviation Kerosene,Jet fuel (JP 54-A1,5), Diesel (Gas Oil) and Fuel Oil D2, D6,ETC in FOB/Rotterdam only, if you want in rotterdam buyer must own tanks in Rotterdam serious buyer should contact or if you have serious buyers my seller is ready to close this deal fast contact us below:now base email us (neftegazagent@yandex.ru)

PRODUCT AVAILABLE IN ROTTERDAM/ CI DIP AND PAY IN SELLER EX-SHORE TANK.

Russia D2 50,000-150,000 Metric Tons FOB Rotterdam Port.

JP54 5000,000 Barrels per Month FOB Rotterdam.

JA1 Jet Fuel 10,000,000 Barrels FOB Rotterdam.

D6 Virgin Fuel Oil 800,000,000 Gallon FOB Rotterdam.

E-mail: neftegazagent@yandex.ru
E: neftegazagent@mail.ru
Skype: neftegazagent

Best Regards
(Mr.) Vladislav Yakov
Skype: neftegazagent

Thank You

Vladislav YakovApril 2nd, 2019 at 6:26 am

We Can supply Aviation Kerosene,Jet fuel (JP 54-A1,5), Diesel (Gas Oil) and Fuel Oil D2, D6,ETC in FOB/Rotterdam only, if you want in rotterdam buyer must own tanks in Rotterdam serious buyer should contact or if you have serious buyers my seller is ready to close this deal fast contact us below:now base email us (neftegazagent@yandex.ru)

Andrey AnkudimovMay 1st, 2019 at 12:27 pm

We OOO PROM TRADING is one of the leading Oil & Gas
trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST 305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG,
LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO) ETC. We as well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both
at Russian ports and Rotterdam port.

Best Regards

Mr Andrey Ankudimov

Tel: +7 (987) 897-72-99

Email: serviceandrey.a@inbox.ru

Skype: serviceandrey.a

BaevMay 3rd, 2019 at 8:25 am

PRODUCT BELOW IS AVAILABLE IN SELLERS TANK IN ROTTERDAM AND HOUSTON
JP54,A1,D2,D6,EN590,MAZUT M100 GOST,LIQUEFIED PETROLEUM GAZ,PETCOKE,AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO),UREA.
EMAIL:alexandrovish60@inbox.ru
Skype:alexandrovish60

Andrey AnkudimovMay 5th, 2019 at 3:49 pm

We OOO PROM TRADING is one of the leading Oil & Gas
trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST 305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG,
LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO) ETC. We as well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both
at Russian ports and Rotterdam port.

Best Regards

Mr Andrey Ankudimov

Tel: +7 (987) 897-72-99

Email: serviceandrey.a@inbox.ru

Skype: serviceandrey.a

Mr AlekseyMay 7th, 2019 at 9:35 am

Dear Sir/ Madam

We are direct Crude Oil Mandate. We have the following products available and ready for purchase; JP54 Aviation Kerosene Fuel, Jet Fuel A1, D2 Gas Oil , and D6 Virgin Fuel Oil,We also represent reputable tank farms for sublease tanks for the storage of petroluem products contact for SCO/Tank storage application form, Ready for Buyers and resellers.
Regard
Aleksey Alexandrovich
Email:surgutneftgz@inbox.ru
Skype: Aleksey Alexandrovich
Tel:+79772862344

baevMay 14th, 2019 at 7:22 pm

Good Day Sir/Madam

We CLOSED JOINT-STOCK COMPANY AGS-OIL is one of the leading Oil & Gas
trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation
and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the
following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST
305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG,
LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO). We as
well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous
buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries
to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both
at Russian ports and Rotterdam port. interested buyer contact us via
email:baevsergeyalexandrovich2289@gmail.com

baev sergeyMay 14th, 2019 at 11:00 pm

We CLOSED JOINT-STOCK COMPANY AGS OIL is one of the leading Oil & Gas trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST 305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG, LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO). We as well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both at Russian ports and Rotterdam port. we also have a reliable SHIPPING COMPANY if you are in need of find the contact bellow.
Email: baevsergeyalexandrovich@bk.ru
BAEVSERGEY ALEXANDROVICH.

Andrey AnkudimovMay 18th, 2019 at 9:01 am

We OOO PROM TRADING is one of the leading Oil & Gas
trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST 305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG,
LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO) ETC. We as well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both
at Russian ports and Rotterdam port.

Best Regards
Mr Andrey Ankudimov
Tel: +7 (987) 897-72-99
Email: serviceandrey.a@inbox.ru
Skype: serviceandrey.a

AlexMay 19th, 2019 at 9:20 am

We "CLOSED JOINT-STOCK COMPANY "AGS-OIL" is one of the leading Oil & Gas trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST 305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG, LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO). We as well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both at Russian ports and Rotterdam port. Contact us on the following email for prompt responses. Contact us with our information below for soft co-operate offer SCO.
Email: dodgewallaceoilcompany@mail.ru

baevMay 19th, 2019 at 3:26 pm

Good Day Sir/Madam

We CLOSED JOINT-STOCK COMPANY AGS-OIL is one of the leading Oil & Gas trading companies in Russia Federation with good business reputation and well experienced in the Petroleum and mining sector. We offer the following trades through our reliable Refineries: D2 DIESEL OIL GOST 305-82, JP54 AVIATION KEROSENE COLONIAL GRADE, UREA 46%/PRILLS, LNG, LPG, REBCO, MAZUT100 GOST 10585-75/99, AUTOMOTIVE GAS OIL(AGO). We as well secure allocations from our various Refineries for our numerous buyers who are interested in Spot transactions on FOB/CIF deliveries to any world safe port (AWSP). Our Refineries have their products both at Russian ports and Rotterdam port. interested buyer contact via email (baevsergealexandrovich@gmail.com)

Aleksey VladislavMay 21st, 2019 at 3:54 pm

Tank Storage Sub Leasing (Rotterdam) (Russia Port) & Petroleum Products available for the serious at Rotterdam & Russia Federation/ official mandates to Refinery for the sales of (JP54, Jet A1,) and also D2 and D6 virgin fuel Oil. CI Dip and Pay FOB PROCEDURE VESSEL TO TANK FOB Rotterdam Transaction available. Kindly contact me on this Email: xcon.oilandgascompany@mail.ru
Director
Skype: Aleksey Vladislav
Whats App: +79268011710
Best Regards