What is the recent increase in U.S. jobless claims telling us?

The jobs picture is looking grim. Jobless claims for the week ending 14 Feb 2009 were 627,000, pushing the average to 619,000. Additionally, nearly 5 million people are staying on the unemployment roles, the highest figure ever. But, it should be a given that jobless claims have increased in this cycle — the U.S. population has increased. What do these figures really mean?

The number itself is largely meaningless except as a talking point for journalists comparing this recession to previous downturns. How many times have you heard the phrase: “this is the largest number since 1982?” Dozens of times, I bet. Unemployment is a lagging indicator and doesn’t tell us anything about whether the economy is going to rebound. What we need to divine from the number is how it predicts future employment, and therefore future spending and economic growth. That’s going to be important whether you are looking for a job investing money or are looking to strategize for your business.

Here’s my brief look into how one can do that (for a more in-depth analysis, see my October post “The Economy’s Four Horsemen“). When the economy starts to slow, it is usually starts with consumers pulling back somewhat, followed by business realizing they need to pull back in turn. This leads to job losses and a further pull back. The cycle of retrenchment eventually ends and consumers begin spending again. But, what you should notice is that consumers lead and companies follow. That means employment falls only after it is apparent that the economy is slowing, and employment continues to fall even after the economy starts to pick up. So, employment is a lagging indicator.

What is not a lagging indicator is the increase in unemployment. In business cycles I have studied, the 6-month or 12-month change in unemployment is a good gauge of the economy. Translation: if you can compare today to six months ago and the jobs picture looks worse (on a relative basis) than it did last month when you did the same exercise, that means the economy is deteriorating.

Now, there are any number of ways to represent this comparison. You can look at the 12-month change in the unemployment rate. You can use the look at the 12-month change in the number of unemployed, and so on. One of my best metrics is jobless claims. More precisiely, I look at the “12-month change in the 4-week average unadjusted number of initial unemployment claims.” That’s a mouthful, so let’s call this stat the “jobless claims change (JCC).”

What the JCC tells us is the rate of deterioration or improvement in the employment market, which very much more of a coincident or leading indicator than unemployment (see my post “Another Perfect Recession Indicator‘ for more). If the JCC increases a lot and is still increasing, that means the jobs picture is getting worse at a more rapid rate, which means that the economy is also deteriorating.

Below are two charts for jobless claims.



The above two charts indicate that the JCC reached a peak of 326,000 two weeks ago and has since fallen to 292,000. If this trend continues, it would indicate an improvement in the economy. However, two weeks, do not a trend make. Moreover, the continuing claims versions of the same charts show further deterioration i.e. an acceleration in the worsening of unemployment. And, all of these charts show a jobs picture on par with the deep recession of 1974.



So, the long and short of this is: the jury is still out on how quickly things are deteriorating. I fully expect an ugly unemployment number for February and double-digit inflation before this is over. Because of inventory de-stocking, I also expect a poor GDP number for this quarter as well. But, let’s not get all doom & gloom here. The numbers are plateauing right now.  By the end of March, things could look very different.

Source Unemployment Insurance Weekly Claims Report – U.S. Department of Labor

Related Reading:

Dire Predictions: Understanding Global Warming
Government Finance Statistics Yearbook 2007
Clinical Prediction Models: A Practical Approach to Development, Validation, and Updating (Statistics for Biology and Health)
The Late Great United States: What Bible Prophecy Reveals about America’s Last Days
Out of Work: Unemployment and Government in Twentieth-Century America

Related posts Are US jobless claims telling us something? U.S. jobless claims: Claims rise 62,000 to 589,000 U.S. jobless claims foreshadow an ugly unemployment number Jobless claims fall again due to seasonality Average U.S. jobless claims top 600,000

Originally published at Credit Writedowns and reproduced here with the author’s permission.

2 Responses to "What is the recent increase in U.S. jobless claims telling us?"

  1. Anonymous   February 19, 2009 at 11:56 pm

    Perfect goobledoogeek economic theory, which has led us into this crises.How does one put the carriage of spending before the horse of employment, is completely out of this world.Wake up, smell the coffee.

  2. Anonymous   February 20, 2009 at 12:37 am

    You do smell the coffee. Good explanation on how consumers’ spending impacts employment and the significance of the rate of change for a better understanding of the future direction.